Laser research: Cellular mechanism, abstract and studies
More than 30 year ago the first publications about low-power laser therapy or photobiomodulation (at that time called laser biostimulation) appeared. Since then approximately 2000 studies have been published on this topic (analysis of these publications can be found in ). Medical treatment with coherent light sources (lasers) or noncoherent light (Light Emitting Diodes, LED's) has passed through its childhood and early maturity. Photobiomodulation is being used by physiotherapists (to treat a wide variety of acute and chronic muscosceletal aches and pains), dentists (to treat inflamed oral tissues, and to heal diverse ulcerations), dermatologists (to treat oedema, indolent ulcers, burns, dermatitis), rheumatologists (relief of pain, treatment of chronic inflammations and autoimmune diseases), and by other specialists (e.g., for treatment of middle and inner ear diseases, nerve regeneration). Photobiomodulation is also used in veterinary medicine (especially in racehorse training centers) and in sports medicine and rehabilitation clinics (to reduce swelling and hematoma, relief of pain and improvement of mobility and for treatment of acute soft tissue injuries). Lasers and LED's are applied directly to respective areas (e.g., wounds, sites of injuries) or to various points on the body (acupuncture points, muscle trigger points). For details of clinical applications and techniques used, the books [ 1-3] are recommended.
The field of photobiomodulation is characterized by variety of methodologies and use of various light sources (lasers, LED's) with different parameters (wavelength, output power, continuous wave or pulsed operation modes, pulse parameters). These parameters are usually given in manufacturers manuals.
The GaAlAs diodes are used both in diode lasers and LED's, the difference is whether the device contains the resonator (as the laser does) or not (LED). In latter years, longer wavelengths (-800-900 nm) and higher output powers (to 100 mW) are preferred in therapeutic devices.
Should a medical doctor use a laser or a diode? The answer is - it depends on what one irradiates, in other words, how deep tissue layers must be irradiated. By light interaction with a biotissue, coherent properties of laser light are not manifested at the molecular level. The absorption of low-intensity laser light by biological systems is of a purely noncoherent (i.e., photobiological) nature. On the cellular level, the biological responses are determined by absorption of light with photoacceptor molecules (see the section 3 below). Coherent properties of laser light are not important when cellular monolayers, thin layers of cell suspension as well as thin layers of tissue surface are irradiated (Fig. 1). In these cases, the coherent and noncoherent light (i.e., both lasers and LED's) with the same wavelength, intensity and dose provides the same biological response. Some additional (therapeutical) effects from the coherent and polarized radiation (lasers) can occur in deeper layers of bulk tissue only and they are connected with random interference of light waves. An interested reader is guided to the ref.  for more details. Here we illustrate this situation by Fig. 1. Large volumes of tissue can be irradiated by laser sources only because the length of longitudinal coherence Lcoh is too small for noncoherent radiation sources .
A photobiological reaction involves the absorption of a specific wavelength of light by the functioning photoacceptor molecule. The photobiological nature of photobiomodulation means that some molecule (photoacceptor) must first absorb the light used for the irradiation. After promotion of electronically excited states, primary molecular processes from these states can lead to a measurable biological effect (via secondary biochemical reaction, or photosignal transduction cascade, or cellular signaling) at the cellular level. The question is, which molecule is the photoacceptor.
When considering the cellular effects, this question can be answered by action spectra. Any graph representing a photoresponse as a function of wavelength, wave number, frequency, or photon energy, is called action spectrum. Action spectra have a highest importance for identifying the photoacceptor inasmuch as the action spectrum of a biological response resembles the absorption spectrum of the photoacceptor molecule. Existence of a structured action spectrum is strong evidence that the phenomenon under study is a photobiological one (i.e., primary photoacceptors and cellular signaling pathways exist). Fig. 2 represents some examples of action spectra for eukaryotic cells: two of them (A, B) consider the processes occurring in cell nucleus, and one spectrum (C) is for cell membrane. Fig. 2D shows the absorption spectrum of the monolayer of the same cells.
The spectra in Fig. 2 represent the red-to-near infrared (IR) region only, i.e. the region that is most important for photobiomodulation. The action spectra for full visibleto-near IR region can be found in . In  one can find action spectra for various cellular responses for other eukaryotic and prokaryotic cells as well.
Two conclusions can be drawn from action spectra in Fig. 2. First, the similarity of the action spectra for different cellular responses suggests that the primary photoacceptor is the same for all these responses. Second, the existence of the action spectra for biochemical processes occurring in various cellular organelles (nucleus, Fig. 2A, B and plasma membrane, Fig. 2C) assume the existence of cellular signaling pathways inside of a cell between the photoacceptor and the nucleus as well as between the photoacceptor and cell membrane. Action spectra also indicate, which wavelengths are the best for irradiation: maximal biological responses are occurring when irradiated at 620, 680, 760 and 820-830 nm (maxima of the spectra in Fig. 2). Skipping over the story of identifying the photoacceptor (described in ) let us conclude that photoacceptor for eukaryotic cells in red-to-near IR region is believed to be the terminal enzyme of the respiratory chain cytochrome c oxidase (located in cell mitochondrion). To be more exact, it is a mixed valence (partially reduced) form of this enzyme, which has not yet been identified. In the violet-to-blue spectral region, flavoproteins (e.g., NADHdehydrogenase in the beginning of the respiratory chain) are also among the photoacceptors as well terminal oxidases.
An important point has to be emphasized. When the excitable cells (e.g., neurons, cardiomyocites) are irradiated with monochromatic visible light, the photoacceptors are also believed to be components of respiratory chain. Some of the experimental evidence concerning excitable cells is shortly summarized in Fig. 3. It is quite clear from experimental data (reviewed in ) that irradiation can cause physiological and morphological changes in nonpigmental excitable cells via absorption in mitochondria. Later, similar irradiation experiments were performed with neurons in connection with low-power laser therapy. It was shown in 80's that He-Ne laser radiation alters the firing pattern of nerves; it was also found that transcutaneous irradiation with HeNe laser mimicked the effect of peripheral stimulation of a behavioral reflex. These findings were found to be connected with pain therapy (review ).
So, what happens when the molecule of photoacceptor absorbs photons? Answer - electronic excitation followed by photochemical reactions occurring from lower excitation states (first singlet and triplet). It is also known that electronic excitation of absorbing centers alters their redox properties. Until yet, five primary reactions have been discussed in literature (Fig. 4). Two of them are connected with alteration of redox properties and two mechanisms involve generation of reactive oxygen species (ROE). Also, induction of local transient (very short time) heating of absorbing chromophors is possible. Details of these mechanisms can be found in [4, 5].
There is no ground to believe that only one of the reactions shown in Fig. 4 occurs when a cell is irradiated and excited electronic states are promoted. The question is, which mechanism is decisive. It is not excluded that all mechanisms shown in Fig. 4 lead to a similar result, to a modulation of redox state of the mitochondria (a shift to more oxidized direction). However, depending on the light dose and intensity used, some mechanism(s) can prevail significantly .
The next question is, the following if photoacceptors are located in the mitochondria, then how the primary reactions occurring under irradiation in the respiratory chain (Fig. 4) are connected with DNA and RNA synthesis in the nucleus (the action spectra in Fig. 2A, B) or with changes in plasma membrane (Fig. 2C)? The principal answer is that between these events there are secondary (dark) reactions (cellular signaling cascades or photosignal transduction and amplification, Fig. 5).
Three regulation pathways are suggested in Fig. 4. The first one is the control of photoacceptor over the level of intracellular ATP. It is known tat even small changes in ATP level can alter cellular metabolism significantly. This regulation way is especially important by irradiation of hypoxic, starving or otherways stressed cells. However, in many cases the regulative role of redox homeostasis is proved to be more important than that of ATP. For example, it is known that the susceptibility of cells to hypoxic injury depends more on the capacity of cells to maintain the redox homeostasis and less on their capacity to maintain the energy status.
The second and third regulation pathways are mediated through the cellular redox state (Eh; Fig. 4). This way involve redox-sensitive transcription factors (NF-KB and AP1, Fig. 4) or cellular signaling homeostatic cascades from cytoplasma via cells membrane to the nucleus (Fig. 4). As a whole, the scheme in Fig. 4 suggests a shift in overcell redox potential into more oxidized direction. Modulation of cellular redox state affects gene expression namely via transcription factors. It is important that in spite of some similar or even identical steps in cellular signaling, the final cellular responses to the irradiation differ due to existence of different modes of regulation of transcription factors. The mechanisms of regulation are not understood well yet.
The magnitude of cellular responses depends on cellular redox potential (and its physiological status, respectively) at the moment of irradiation. The cellular response is stronger when the redox potential of the target cell is initially shifted to a more reduced state (and intracellular pH, pH;, is lowered, as usually happens in injured cells). This explains why the degrees of cellular responses can differ markedly in different experiments or in different clinical cases, and why the effects are sometimes nonexistent.
One should emphasize that some biological limitations exist for photobiomodulation effects. These are discussed in .
The redox regulation mechanism cannot occur solely via respiratory chain (Section 3). Other redox chains containing molecules, which absorb light in visible-to-near IR radiation, and are some key structures that can regulate a metabolic pathway, can be photoacceptors for photobiomodulation as well. One such example is NADPH-oxidase of phagocytic cells, which is responsible for nonmitochondrial respiratory burst. This multicomponent enzyme system located in the plasma membrane is a redox chain that generates reactive oxygen species (ROS) as a response to the microbicidal or other types of activation. Irradiation with He-Ne laser and diode lasers and LED's can activate this chain in various phagocytic cells. Many worked examples can be found in . In phagocytes, the activation of respiratory chains in mitochondria occurs as well, as NADHP-oxidase activation, but the latter is much stronger.
ROS, burst of which is induced by direct irradiation of phagocytes, can activate or inactivate other cells, which were not irradiated directly. In this way, indirect activation or suppression of metabolic pathways in non-irradiated cells occurs. Also, lymphokines and cytokines produced by irradiated lymphocytes can influence metabolism of other cells. This situation is common by irradiation on tissues.
The photobiological action mechanism via activation of respiratory chain is a universal working mechanism for various cells. Crucial events of this type of cell metabolism activation are occurring due to a shift of cellular redox potential into more oxidized direction as well as due to ATP extrasynthesis. Susceptibility to irradiation and capability for activation depend on physiological status of irradiated cells: the cells, which overall redox potential is shifted to more reduced state (example: some pathological conditions) are more sensitive to the irradiation. The specificity of final photobiological response is determined not at the level of primary reactions in the respiratory chain but at the transcription level during cellular signaling cascades. In some cells, only partial activation of cell metabolism happens by this mechanism (example: redox priming of lymphocytes).
All light-induced biological effects depend on the parameters of the irradiation (wavelength, dose, intensity, irradiation time, and continuous wave or pulsed mode, pulse parameters). According to action spectra, optimal wavelengths are 820-830, 760, 680, and 620 nn. Large volumes and deeper layers of tissues can successfully irradiated by laser only (e.g. inner and middle ear diseases, injured siatic or optical nerves, deep inflammations etc.). The LED's are excellent for irradiation of surface injuries.
Herbert Klima Atomic Institute of the Austrian Universities, Vienna, Austria
Biophysical aspects of low level laser therapy will be discussed from two points of view: from the electromagnetic and the thermodynamical point of view. From electromagnetic point of view, living systems are mainly governed by he electromagnetic interaction whose interacting particles are called photons. Each interaction beween molecules, macromolecules or living cells is basically electromagnetic and governed by photons. For this reason, we must expect that electromagnetic influences like laser light of proper wavelength will have remarkable impact on the regulation of living processes. An impressive example of this regulating function of various wavelengths of light is found in the realm of botany, where photons of 660 nm are able to trigger the growth of plants which leads among other things to the formation of buds. On the other hand, irradiation of plants by 730 nm photons may stopp the growth and the flowering. Human phagocyting cells are natively emitting light which can be detected by single photon counting methods. Singlet oxygen molecules are the main sources of this light emitted at 480, 570, 633, 760, 1060 and 1270 nm wavelengths. On the other hand, human cells (leukocytes, lymphocytes, stem cells, fibroblasts, etc) can be stimulated by low power laser light of just these wavelengths.
From thermodynamical point of view, living systems - in contrast to dead organisms - are open systems which need metabolism in order to maintain their highly ordered state of life. Such states can only exist far from thermodynamical equilibrium thus dissipating heat in order to maintain their high order and complexity. Such nonequilibrium systems are called dissipative structures proposed by the Nobel laureat I. Prigogine. One of the main feature of dissipative structures is their ability to react very sensibly on weak influences, e.g. they are able to amplify even very small stimuli. Therefore, we must expect that even weak laser light of proper wavelength and proper irradiation should be able to influence the dynamics of regulation in living systems. For example, the transition from a cell at rest to a dividing one will occur during a phase transition allready influenced by the tinest fluctuations. External stimuli can induce these phase transitions which would otherwise not even take place. These phase transitions induced by light can be impressively illustrated by various chemical and physiological reactions as special kinds of dissipative systems.
One of he most important biochemical reaction localized in mitochondria is the oxidation of NADH in the respiatory chain of aerobic cells. A similar reaction has been found to be a dissipative process showing oscillating and chaotic behaviour capable to absorb and amplify photons of proper wavelength. A great variety of experimental and clinical results in the field of low level laser therapy supports these two biophysical points of view concerning the interaction beween life and laser light. Our former, but also our recent experimental results on the effects of low level laser light on human cells are steps in this direction. By using cytometric, photometric and radiochemical methods it is shown that the increase or decrease of cells growth depends on the applied wavelenghts (480, 570, 633, 700, 760, 904, 1060, 1270 nm), on the irradiance (100 - 5000 J/m2), on the pulse sequence modulated to laser beams (constant, periodic, chaotic pulses), on the type of cells (leukocytes, lymphocytes, fibroblasts, normal and cancer cells) and on the density of the cells in tissue cultures.
Our experimental results support our hypothesis which states that triplet oxygen molecules are able to absorb proper laser light at wavelenght at wavelenghts 480, 570, 633, 700, 760, 904, 1060, 1270 nm thus producing singlet oxygen molecules. Singlet oxygen takes part in many metabolic processes, e.g. catalytic oxydation of NADH which has been shown to be a dissipative system far from thermodynamical equilibrium and sensitive even to small stimuli. Therfore, laser light of proper wavelenght and irradiance in low level laser therapy is assumed to be able to exicte oxygen molecules thus influencing or amplifying metabolism and consequently influencing and supporting fundamental healing processes
Hinweis: Die Lasertherapie (LLLT) ist in Deutschland wissenschaftlich noch nicht anerkannt und gehört zu den komplementären Therapieverfahren.